There's something about lemon pie that combines that great tart citrus taste with just the right amount of sweetness to make your mouth water and your sweet tooth beg for more.
This is a special recipe used by Amish ladies to make this palate-pleasing pie from scratch - not a pre-packaged tube of filling.
You can use your own favorite recipe for the crust or one of any number of pre made pie crusts available. But if, of course, you want to impress your friends and family that it didn't come from a box - try the pie dough recipe given after the lemon pie filling recipe.
2 C. boiling water
2 T. cornstarch or clear jel
1 C. sugar
rind of 1/2 lemon
juice of 1 lemon
1 T. butter
Mix cornstarch and sugar. Slowly add boiling water, stirring constantly. Cook until mixture thickens. Remove from heat and add beaten egg yolks, butter, lemon rind and juice. Cook 1 minute. Pour into baked pastry crust. Top with meringue or whipped cream.
Recipe taken from Cooking With The Horse & Buggy People Vol. I submitted by Mrs. John A. Weaver.
2 1/4 C. lard
2 t. baking powder
1 T. vinegar
1 1/2 t. salt
6 C. flour
Put 1 T. vinegar in 1 C. and fill with hot water. Pour over lard and let stand until soft. Stir in flour (part whole wheat if you wish), baking powder and salt. Set in cold place overnight. Enough for approximately 6 pies.
Pie Dough recipe taken from Cooking With The Horse & Buggy People Vol. I submitted by Mrs. Emma Hershberger.
Like this recipe? Want some more great Amish Recipes? Carlisle Press publishes a cookbook called Cooking with the Horse & Buggy People with over 600 favorite Amish Recipes.
What our readers are saying about Ohio Amish Country Experiences
". . . like to say that I very much enjoy your newsletter . . . the past 15 years have been visiting Ohio Amish Country at least once a year . . . find it to be tranquil & serene; it takes me back to a time when life was not so complicated and makes everything seem so peaceful . . . your newsletter takes me back to that peaceful feeling."
Looking for a great travel guide to help you find your way around Northeast Ohio Amish Country? Find out where to go and how to get there! Get your Experience Northeast Ohio Amish Country Road Map Now!
Need a great travel guide to help you find your way around the "Heart of Ohio Amish Country?" Find out where to go and how to get there! Get your Map of Ohio's Amish Highways and Byways Now!