Amish Peanut Butter Delight Pie

This Amish Peanut Butter Delight Pie recipe will enable you to experience the absolute sheer "delight of dessert" right from your own home or kitchen!

Homemade pies are a well known "trademark dessert" with Amish-style cooking. There's nothing quite like a good piece of homemade pie to top off a great meal.

You'll definitely want to give this recipe a try - it combines two of the food greats (those being chocolate and peanut butter) and, it's as easy as . . . well, easy as pie.

After our sacrificial testing (tough job - but somebody had to do it), our family gave it a "two forks way up" approval rating!

You can make your own pie crust - regular or graham cracker. Or, if you're in hurry, you can use a ready-made crust of your choosing.

Garnish of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups added to top
in photo not part of the recipe.


First Layer:
8 oz. cream cheese
1 c. powdered sugar
3/4 c. peanut butter
8 oz. whipped topping

Mix together and spread on crust.

Second Layer:
1 (3 oz.) pkg. Vanilla pudding
1 (3 oz.) pkg. Chocolate pudding
3 c. milk
8 oz. whipped topping

Beat puddings, milk and enough whipped topping to make creamy. Spread on top of first layer. Top with remaining whipped topping.

Recipe makes 2 large pies. We added some Reese's Peanut Butter Cup chunks on the top as a "complimentary" garnish - an excellent choice!

amish-wedding-cookbookEnjoy this recipe? Want more? Amish Wedding Foods publishes a cookbook called The Amish Wedding Story & Cookbook with over 300 favorite Amish Recipes.

Only $11.98 Click here for more information.

Other Recipes

Return from Amish Peanut Butter Delight Pie to Amish Recipes

Amish Country, Ohio, weather forecast

Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter

Ohio Amish Country Experiences

Your E-mail Address

Your First Name (optional)


Your e-mail address is totally secure.
We only use it to send you
Ohio Amish Country Experiences.

What our readers are saying about Ohio Amish Country Experiences

". . . like to say that I very much enjoy your newsletter . . . the past 15 years have been visiting Ohio Amish Country at least once a year . . . find it to be tranquil & serene; it takes me back to a time when life was not so complicated and makes everything seem so peaceful . . . your newsletter takes me back to that peaceful feeling."

Lawrenceburg, KY

Click Image for More Information

Looking for a great travel guide to help you find your way around Northeast Ohio Amish Country? Find out where to go and how to get there! Get your Experience Northeast Ohio Amish Country Road Map Now!

SBI! Case Studies

Click Image for More Information

Need a great travel guide to help you find your way around the "Heart of Ohio Amish Country?" Find out where to go and how to get there! Get your Map of Ohio's Amish Highways and Byways Now!